Korea Times, September 3, 2007
By Yoon Won-sup
Staff Reporter
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade finds itself in a very awkward situation as it apparently lost a diplomatic edge to the National Intelligence Service (NIS) in the process of ending the hostage crisis in Afghanistan.
Not a senior diplomat but Kim Man-bok, director of the spy agency, turned out to have led negotiations with the Taliban militants for the release of the hostages and returned home Sunday with released hostages, placing him in the spotlight of the nation and the press.
In a rare move, Kim praised the role of the NIS for the successful negotiation.
During a press briefing, Kim even introduced an NIS official wearing sunglasses, who was captured on the cameras of several television networks, as being a main contributor to the release through a fluency in the Afghan language _ Pashto.
``He speaks English very well and also Pashto,'' Kim told reporters. ``The Taliban negotiators seemed to have felt strong familiarity thanks to his language ability.''
Kim's praise of the Pashto-speaking official is virtually a criticism to the ministry, which has no expert on Afghanistan.
The lack of experts on regions, particularly, the Middle East, Central Asia and Africa, is mainly due to the U.S.-oriented structure of the ministry, according to experts.
When the ministry found out that the Taliban kidnapped the 23 Koreans in July, it sent Arabic professors for negotiation and information to Afghanistan. But the ministry realized later that it was not Arabic but Pashto that is spoken in Afghanistan
This example shows how seriously the ministry lacks experts on the Central Asian country while the ministry has so many experts on the United States and other powers.
``The hostage crisis should be a good occasion to transform the U.S.-oriented ministry to the balanced ministry,'' Lee Geun, professor of the Graduate School of International Studies at Seoul National University, told The Korea Times. ``So far, the ministry was very much focused on the United States and other Western powers.''
Lee said the ministry faces pressure to pay more attention to small and weak countries.
There was even a saying within the ministry that to become a minister, he or she should have served as director-general of the North American Bureau because Korea's diplomacy is closely tied with the United States. Song Min-soon, the minister of foreign affairs and trade, and Ban Ki-moon, former minister, both had served as director-general of North American Bureau.
The ministry's lack of information was first shown in the first stage of the crisis.
When Cho Yong-hee, the ministry spokesman, announced on July 20 that the ministry had obtained secret information on the kidnapped Koreans. But the information actually came from The Korea Times.
A Korea Times reporter obtained the information earlier in the day and requested onfirmation from the ministry. But the ministry just held a press conference about the kidnapping in the afternoon without confirmation or explanation.
Then, Cho Jung-pyo, first vice minister, was immediately sent to Afghanistan but returned home on Aug. 19 without any result.
The NIS chief became the next control tower of the negation as he arrived in Afghanistan on Aug. 22. He came back home with his mission completed Sunday.
Minister Song also agreed his ministry has limited capability to deal with the crisis.
``There were not many areas diplomacy could do,'' he told reporters upon arrival at Incheon International Airport after visiting Middle East countries.
A source, who closely followed the hostage negotiations in Kabul, also criticized the Korean government for not having full knowledge of Afghanistan.
``It was the responsibility of the Korean Embassy in Kabul to let the Koreans know and warn them against traveling to dangerous zones as well as inform them about precautionary measures,'' he said.
Meanwhile, the main opposition Grand National Party said it is inappropriate for the NIS chief to appear in public given that any activities of the spy agency are required to be conducted in secret.
yoonwonsup@koreatimes.co.kr
Recent Comments